Worship Banned at the Civic Center? Why One New Church Filed a Lawsuit against Its Town

Sarah KramerAll Enews

Starting a new church is no easy task.

You need to put together a launch team, fundraise, and advertise. You have paperwork to fill out and bylaws to draft. And then, of course, you need to find a place to worship.

Unfortunately, finding a temporary home proved to be a bit more difficult than one new church bargained for. And that’s what led Redeemer Fellowship of Edisto Island in South Carolina to file a lawsuit.

Let’s take a deeper look at this church, its case, and how it got here.

Who: Redeemer Fellowship of Edisto Island

The lead pastor of Redeemer Fellowship of Edisto Island has long been involved in the community.

For example, he served as president of the local pastors’ alliance, as well as the director of the community choir. In the aftermath of Hurricane Matthew, which devastated the community in 2016, the lead pastor was instrumental in facilitating relief teams and setting up a foodbank. At the town’s request, he even led a community worship service at the Town of Edisto Beach Civic Center in Hurricane Matthew’s aftermath.

So when he launched Redeemer Fellowship at the beginning of 2018 and needed a place to meet, the civic center was an obvious choice. After the new church rented space there in April and May of 2018, it seemed like a natural fit for their worship services moving forward.

But when the church proposed another rental agreement with the civic center, town officials denied the request. Not only that, but in May, the town council changed the civic center rules to ban worship services altogether.

What: Redeemer Fellowship of Edisto Island v. Town of Edisto Beach

What could have changed the town’s mind so suddenly?

It turns out that the town attorney claimed that entering into a rental agreement with Redeemer Fellowship might violate the Constitution’s prohibition on government making any law “respecting an establishment of religion.”

But allowing a church to rent the civic center on the same grounds as everyone else is not an establishment of religion – it’s just fair.

After all, the town welcomes a variety of groups to rent space at the civic center, including “civic, political, business, social groups, and others.” But town officials made it clear that “others” does not include Christians looking for a place to worship.

That’s why Alliance Defending Freedom filed a lawsuit on behalf of Redeemer Fellowship.

Just because the town lets a church rent space at the civic center on the same terms as everyone else does not mean the government is “establishing a religion.” Redeemer Fellowship never asked to be the only church allowed to rent the civic center. It never asked for free advertising urging citizens to attend services. All it asked for is the ability to rent some space on the same terms as everyone else.

That shouldn’t be too much to ask.

When: August 2018 – August 2019 

ADF filed a lawsuit against the town of Edisto Beach in August 2018. In November 2018, a federal district court heard the case.

The U.S. Department of Justice also filed a statement of interest supporting Redeemer Fellowship. As the DOJ’s statement explains, “the Town’s reading of the First Amendment is exactly backwards: the Town seeks to permit the content and viewpoint discrimination against religious worship that the Free Speech and Free Exercise Clauses prohibit and to prohibit the equal access for religious expression that the Establishment Clause permits.”

In December 2018, the Town voluntarily changed its policy to reverse the worship ban. Now churches can rent the civic center on the same terms as every other member of the community. In light of that, both parties filed their agreement to end the lawsuit on August 19, 2019.

Where: Edisto Beach, South Carolina

Redeemer Fellowship of Edisto Island is located in Edisto Beach, South Carolina.

Why: The government cannot treat churches and religious groups worse than everyone else.

By refusing to rent civic center space to Redeemer Fellowship, Edisto Beach officials violated the Constitution on two different counts – denying the church its right to free speech and free exercise of religion.

The U.S. Supreme Court has already made it clear that the government cannot treat religious people and organizations worse than everyone else when it ruled 7-2 in favor of Trinity Lutheran Church of Columbia. In that case, the State of Missouri had blocked Trinity Lutheran from receiving a grant to resurface its playground. The grant program was open to nonprofits in the state of Missouri. Yet, because the playground is operated by a church, the state denied them the grant.

Sound familiar?

The government should never be permitted to treat people of faith as second-class citizens – barring them from benefits that others receive simply because they are religious.

The Bottom Line

Churches should have the same access to public facilities as any other group. Anything less is a clear violation of the Constitution.

Prepare & Protect Your Church

MTSBC partnered with ADF Church Alliance to prepare and protect your church in situations like this and for many other religious freedom issues. Your church can partner with the same advocates who helped Redeemer Fellowship by joining ADF Church Alliance.

ADF Church Alliance is a membership program that provides legal help so you can freely preach and operate your church in accordance with Christian principles. The program acts as a hub for churches to gain legal insights, advice, document review, and even representation in litigation – it’s virtually all-inclusive for religious freedom issues.

Activate your membership by clicking here. Complete the brief application and enter promo code MTSBC20 to get a 20% discount on your first year of membership.

About the Author
Sarah Kramer

Sarah Kramer

Sarah Kramer graduated from Hillsdale College in 2013 with a degree in Political Economy and Journalism. She worked as an investigative reporter before joining the Alliance Defending Freedom team. Sarah married her college sweetheart in August of 2014 and moved to Phoenix shortly thereafter, where she and her husband are excited to settle in and spend winters away from the snow.